Runner up
Juventus (8 kali)
AC Milan (5 kali)
Inter Milan, AS Roma (4 kali)
Lazio, Sampdoria, Parma (3 kali)
Napoli (2 kali)
Fiorentina, Torino, Vicenza (1 kali)
Daftar Juara Supercoppa Italia Sepanjang Sejarah
Berikut daftar juara Supercoppa Italia sepanjang sejarah :
| TAHUN | JUARA | SKOR | RUNNER-UP |
| 1988 | AC Milan | 3-1 | Sampdoria |
| 1989 | Inter Milan | 2-0 | Sampdoria |
| 1990 | Napoli | 5-1 | Juventus |
| 1991 | Sampdoria | 1-0 | AS Roma |
| 1992 | AC Milan | 2-1 | Parma |
| 1993 | AC Milan | 1-0 | Torino |
| 1994 | AC Milan | 1-1 (pen 4-3) | Sampdoria |
| 1995 | Juventus | 1-0 | Parma |
| 1996 | Fiorentina | 2-1 | AC Milan |
| 1997 | Juventus | 3-0 | Vicenza |
| 1998 | Lazio | 2-1 | Juventus |
| 1999 | Parma | 2-1 | AC Milan |
| 2000 | Lazio | 4-3 | Inter Milan |
| 2001 | AS Roma | 3-0 | Fiorentina |
| 2002 | Juventus | 2-1 | Parma |
| 2003 | Juventus | 1-1 (pen 5-3) | AC Milan |
| 2004 | AC Milan | 3-0 | Lazio |
| 2005 | Inter Milan | 1-0 (aet) | Juventus |
| 2006 | Inter Milan | 4-3 (aet) | AS Roma |
| 2007 | AS Roma | 1-0 | Inter Milan |
| 2008 | Inter Milan | 2-2 (pen 6-5) | AS Roma |
| 2009 | Lazio | 2-1 | Inter Milan |
| 2010 | Inter Milan | 3-1 | AS Roma |
| 2011 | AC Milan | 2-1 | Inter Milan |
| 2012 | Juventus | 4-2 (aet) | Napoli |
| 2013 | Juventus | 4-0 | Lazio |
| 2014 | Napoli | 2-2 (pen 6-5) | Juventus |
| 2015 | Juventus | 2-0 | Lazio |
| 2016 | AC Milan | 1-1 (pen 4-3) | Juventus |
| 2017 | Lazio | 3-2 | Juventus |
| 2018 | Juventus | 1-0 | AC Milan |
| 2019 | Lazio | 3-1 | Juventus |
| 2020 | Juventus | 2-0 | Napoli |
| 2021 | Inter Milan | 2-1 (aet) | Juventus |
| 2022 | Inter Milan | 3-0 | AC Milan |
(*)